Demand up at OC domestic violence shelters

July 15, 2009 | Susan Valot | KPCC

Download

When the economy goes down, the number of domestic abuse cases usually goes up. KPCC’s Susan Valot says that seems to be the case in Orange County, where it’s taking more work to place battered women and their children in safe havens.

Susan Valot: Nearly three decades ago, Brenda Clubine was a young wife and mother. Things seemed pretty rosy until the last year of her marriage.

Brenda Clubine: It got real crazy and real violent really fast. I had skull fractures. I had broken bones. I had numerous things. You know, and the injuries just kept getting worse.

Valot: Clubine went back to her husband 11 times. But after another black eye, she called a women’s shelter in Glendale. A woman took her info and then...

Clubine: She said, "Can you please hold?" And she came back on the line a few minutes later and she said, "I’m really sorry. We don’t have any beds right now." She said, "You know, it is getting close to the holidays and I’m really sorry," she said, "but what I can do is, we can – we’ll call you." Which meant that they were going to call my home. And I said, "Oh, I’m sorry." I said, "Never mind. Forget that I ever called."

Valot: A couple of months later, Brenda Clubine’s husband he came at her with a hammer. This time, she hit him with a bottle and killed him. Clubine served 26 years in prison in Chino for murder. She got out less than a year ago. What she found years ago – domestic violence shelters too crowded to take in women – is happening again.

Rocio Watson: (greeting women at shelter as she walks by) Hi ladies!
Women at shelter: Hi.

Watson: One of our groups going on...

Valot: Rocio Watson runs the Women’s Transitional Living Center, one of the main domestic violence shelters in Orange County. She pops her head in to say hello to a group of women, crammed onto flowery couches for a counseling session. Watson says for the first time in her shelter’s three-decade history, they’re referring women elsewhere.

Watson: Unfortunately, due to the financial crisis, we have seen a huge increase in domestic violence. We are completely full – at capacity. That’s in both our emergency shelter and our traditional housing program.

Valot: Watson says some calls are from women who’ve faced violence, but money trouble has magnified it. So Watson says women call to finally try to get out.

Watson: It’s not just us. I mean, in with talking with other people and other agencies that do similar work to what we do, they’re experiencing the same thing, you know. And we’ll call each other and say, "I have this lady on the phone and, you know, we might not be able to accommodate her because we don’t have any room. Do you have any room?" And they’re saying the same thing, "No we don’t."

Valot: Watson says a safety net program puts women in a motel for a week or so, until there’s space in a shelter. But they’ve used up the money for that already this year.

[Sound of re-enacted, typical hotline call at Human Options: (phone rings) "Hotline, can I help you?..."]

Valot: At Human Options, a smaller domestic violence shelter in Orange County, calls similar to this are coming into their domestic violence hotline more often.

[Sound of re-enacted, typical hotline call at Human Options: "Have you heard about our program? OK. This is a domestic violence shelter and we are located in Orange County..."]

Valot: Vivian Clecak is the founder of Human Options. She says in the past year or so, they’ve seen a shift.

Vivian Clecak: Calls have gone up about 25 percent in the emergency shelter. It’s not as much as the calls have gone up at the homeless shelters or food banks. And that’s because what we’re seeing is that women are terrified to leave.

They can’t imagine that they could support their children. Our calls at our counseling centers are up 60 percent. And the crisis level for both the shelter and the counseling centers is even higher.

Valot: Clecak says Human Options counselors are also referring more cases to child protective services.

[Sound from Sin by Silence documentary of 911 call from child in San Diego, screaming as mom is attacked by dad]
Child: He just knocked mommy.
911 Operator: OK.
Child: And he made some red marks on momma's, on momma's neck. [child screams] Oh my God!
911 Operator: What's the matter?
Child: (screaming) Something happened! Mommy! Mommy!
911 Operator: Hello? [dial tone]

Valot: A 911 call in the documentary Sin by Silence shows how domestic violence ripples through families. Domestic abuse survivor Brenda Clubine at times wiped her eyes during a recent screening in Anaheim.

Clubine: What I wish is that women would understand that they’re not alone, that they can make it [Clubine tries to keep her composure] on their own, that they don’t have to stay and that there are people and organizations willing to help them.

Valot: But in this economy, those organizations are struggling.

Domestic violence hotlines:

Women's Transitional Living Center 24-Hour Hotline: (714) 992-1931
Human Options 24-Hour Hotline: toll-free (877) 854-3594 or (949) 854-3554
Laura's House (Orange County) 24-Hour Hotline: toll-free (866)498-1511 (or) 949-498-1511
Los Angeles County Domestic Violence Hotline: toll-free (800) 978-3600
Alternatives to Domestic Violence (Riverside County) 24-Hour Crisis Hotline: (951) 683-0829
Option House (San Bernardino) 24-Hour Hotline: (909) 381-3472
National Domestic Abuse Hotline: 1-800-799-SAFE (7233)


Comments

Don S

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

This story briefly acknowledged that the real problem is increasing homelessness. Compared to homeless shelters, domestic violence shelters would have to be considered luxurious accommodations. The funding per bed is about ten times higher. It would be understandable that anyone needing shelter choose the high price spread. With men being 80 percent of the newly unemployed this story appears strikingly biased. More it is a bias that is aligned with the bias of most domestic violence shelters which actively discriminate against men regardless of how much they have been abused. So the focus of this story is disingenuous, insulting and injurious. That same behavior among intimates is considered domestic violence by California law. Women excusing the behavior in public may partially explain the finding that two thirds of the women in shelters admit that they have been seriously violent to their partner in the prior 12 months. In future I hope the reporter will explore this double standard.

Jennifer

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

The above comment is ridiculous. To say that women who are abused have it better than the homeless man is not an analogy to be regarded.
While it is unacceptable for ANYONE to be abused, it seems the above gentleman believes that men are discriminated against. This program in no way insinuated this comparison. Being homeless in this economy and being abused in this economy are two separate, non gender problems.

R Watson

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

Thank you for helping us spread the word..we need the community's support if we are to continue to provide services to those who are most vulnerable during this economic crisis. Victims of Domestic Violence and Human Trafficking. Please support us by visiting us and making a tax deductible donation directly through our website www.wtlc.org

Harry C

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

Jennifer says, "Being homeless in this economy and being abused in this economy are two separate, non gender problems." It is primarily men who are dis empowered and unemployed rather than women by our current economic downturn; yet services are primarily directed toward women. Clearly then men are being abused by a gender biased system. If women primarily instigate aggressive behavior toward men, that is intimate partner violence (which all reliable research says is true) yet are afforded relatively luxurious shelter accommodations while abused men sleep on the street or bunk in warehouse type facilities then clearly men are being abused by a gender biased system. Since more men than women are becoming unemployed, Obama's stimulus package is largely directed at creating jobs for women, men are in fact abused in large numbers, and men in fact do not have access to the same services and housing opportunities as do abused women, to state that one has nothing to do with the other, that is the economy has noting to do with abuse, or either with the provision of services, is simply ridiculous and ill informed. All are interrelated.

Paul M. Clements

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

Given the decades of study and the reams of data that show that men are abused and battered in equal if not greater numbers than women, one has to wonder why there are no shelters for victimized men. With all the billions (about eight billion and counting) spent on women's agencies by VAWA, why couldn't they find a couple lousy millions to establish a men's shelter in each state? As it is,the only shelters for men are under a bridge, in jail, or in the bone yard.

Ray

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

Domestic violence shelters in California have a long tradition of denying services and shelter to battered men, while rewarding violent women, so why would anyone believe anything those biased, taxpayer subsidized institutions have to say about domestic violence? Domestic violence statistics have been manipulated by those wishing to advance a gender feminist (anti-male) ideology for over a decade. Sadly, we see the bias furthered in numerous, biased pieces of journalism. At the web site "Respecting Accuracy in Domestic Abuse Reporting," there is a lot of documentation of the bias by the domestic violence industry (and mainstream journalism sources) against men. This article will be forwarded to them.

Fred Sottile

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

The President was elected with the "women vote." The President's website has a list of important issues. Women's issues is are on that list, no men's issues. The president picked a running mate who said that his greatest achievemnet was the creation of a gender prejudiced law which is VAWA, the Violence Against (just) Women Act. Why do we have inequity in services to all Americans? To answer that, simply "do the math."

Jim

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

It's great to see some of the above comments that reflect the truth about the biased and misandrous domestic violence industry. May the word spread far and wide that their lies are based on the hatred of men. There are likely some folks who are employed in that industry who have bought the lies but that is no excuse. Research it yourself and see what you find. Start by googling "fiebert" and choosing the first link.

I say tear it down and build a system that cares for all people not just the chosen few.

Tim G

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

At least those commenting know what the survey evidence has been telling us for decades: Women initiate and perpetrate domestic violence, at every level of violence, at rates equal to or greater than the reverse.

Shame on those whose empathy extends exclusively to women.

gary c

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

Boy, how'd so many mens rights activists get their comments in amongst the deluge of comments by all the abused females ("it's an epidemic"). Answer: there is no epidemic, women are being served to the nth degree, men are being ignored, and many men are fighting back!

Masculist

1 year, 1 month ago

Link to this comment

It is dehumanizing how society still seems to care more about the health and welfare of women than that of men. This kind of chivalry is sexist against males. One just has to go to mediaradar.org to see just how real the issue of battered husbands is. I hope that the domestic violence industry will start treating men with the same level of compassion that it currently does for women.

It is sad how men comprise the vast majority of the homeless, suicides, those in prison, war casualties, and those who die on the job.

It is not always women who are damsels in distress. Men can be victims too. Men are not less "human" than women. All people have a right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Men are human beings with feelings. They are not cannon fodder or walking ATM machines whose only purpose is to serve and protect.

New comments disabled after 14 days