Jail violence commission grills LA sheriff, undersheriff

Paul Tanaka Hearing

Bear Guerra/KPCC

Undersherrif Paul Tanaka prepares to testify in front of the Citizens Commission on Jail Violence on Friday, July 27, 2012. The commission was formed by the LA County Board of Supervisors to investigate allegations of abuse at county jails.

Paul Tanaka Hearing

Bear Guerra/KPCC

Members of the Los Angeles County sheriff's department wait for Undersheriff Paul Tanaka's hearing to begin with the County Board of Supervisors on July 27, 2012.

Paul Tanaka Hearing

Bear Guerra/KPCC

A crowd comprised primarily of members of the LA County Sheriff's department attended the July 27, 2012 hearing during which Undersheriff Paul Tanaka testified about allegations of abuse in county jails.

Paul Tanaka Hearing

Bear Guerra/KPCC

Attorney Bert Deixler is seen on a monitor as he questions Undersheriff Paul Tanaka about allegations of abuse in LA County jails.

Paul Tanaka Hearing

Bear Guerra/KPCC

Undersherrif Paul Tanaka testifies in front of the Citizens Commission on Jail Violence on Friday, July 27, 2012. The commission was formed by the LA County Board of Supervisors to investigate allegations of abuse at county jails.

Paul Tanaka Hearing

Bear Guerra/KPCC

County Supervisors listen as Undersheriff Paul Tanaka responds to questions about an email memo during a hearing regarding allegations of abuse in county jails.

Paul Tanaka Hearing

Bear Guerra/KPCC

Undersherrif Paul Tanaka arrives for a hearing with the Citizens Commission on Jail Violence on Friday, July 27, 2012.


Los Angeles County Sheriff Lee Baca faced sharp questioning from the Citizen’s Commission on Jail Violence Friday about inmate abuse by his deputies.

The panel’s chief lawyer Richard Drooyan pointed out that annual reports for eight years indicated a “significant spike” in use of force against inmates at Men’s Central Jail in downtown L.A. He asked why the sheriff failed to address the increase.

Baca offered varying responses, as more than 100 uniformed deputies and commanders sat in the audience at the County Hall of Administration.

“Use of force statistics only tell you so much,” he said. Later, he added that subordinates failed to inform him about misconduct and “let me down.”

At one point, the sheriff wanted to move on from the subject. “There are limits to digging up dirt," he said. “We know we screwed up in the past.”

The L.A. County Board of Supervisors created the panel after the FBI launched an investigation into allegations of widespread abuse of inmates. The ACLU has collected more than 100 declarations from inmates who say deputies beat them up.

Before Baca testified, the sheriff’s little-known but powerful second-in-command endured four hours of grilling about his role at the jails.

Undersheriff Paul Tanaka offered testy denials when confronted with previous testimony from jail captains who said they warned him that deputies were engaging in excessive use of force.

“That’s a fictional account,” he said. “No one brought it to my attention.” Tanaka oversaw the jails from 2005-2007.

He said he could not remember a number of meetings described by other Sheriff’s officials in which Tanaka was presented information about misconduct.

“I was astounded that you didn’t know,” said former federal judge Dick Tevrizian, who sits on the panel. “It seems like everybody buried their head in sand.”

The undersheriff addressed a litany of complaints against him. Tanaka denied that he encouraged misconduct by telling deputies to operate in the “gray area.” He said he never intended to undermine an internal affairs investigations into misconduct — despite criticizing those investigations.

Tanaka said any criticism of him came from subordinates who had “personal agendas.”

Baca backed up his undersheriff and reacted strongly when asked why he hasn’t done more to hold his senior staff accountable for festering misconduct at the jails.

“You’re not going to tell me how to discipline my people,” he said.

Use of force has declined at the jails in recent months as Baca has paid more attention to his lockups. He’s written new use of force policies and installed new management at Men’s Central Jail that reports directly to him — not Tanaka.

“When the day is done… I’m to blame,” Baca said as he wrapped up his comments.

Drooyan asked how the sheriff should be held accountable.

“Don’t elect me,” said the four-term sheriff.

The room erupted in laughter.

The commission is expected to issue recommendations for jail reform later this year.

More in Crime

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus