Environment & Science

Will California's earthquake warning system run the risk of alert fatigue?

An aerial view of damage to the I-5 to Highway 14 connector ramp following the Northridge earthquake, on Jan. 17, 1994.
An aerial view of damage to the I-5 to Highway 14 connector ramp following the Northridge earthquake, on Jan. 17, 1994.
Carlos Chiebeck/AFP/Getty Images

The choice comes down to seconds — but even that could be the difference between safety and harm.

A new study from the U.S. Geological Survey lays out the dilemma facing scientists working on earthquake warning systems: Do you alert early and often, or wait until you know it's a strong temblor and possibly be too late?

The study, released this week, calculates the earliest possible time a warning system could let people know shaking was imminent. The findings could be used to decide protocols for ShakeAlert, the earthquake early warning system currently being developed for the West Coast.

How the U.S.G.S. alert system ShakeAlert will make use of sensors to detect earthquakes.
How the U.S.G.S. alert system ShakeAlert will make use of sensors to detect earthquakes.
U.S.G.S.

What makes such timing hard is that when an earthquake first begins, there's no way to know if it will ultimately be small or large.

So there's concern about earthquake warning fatigue, particularly in regions like Southern California where minor earthquakes are common. 

“The conundrum is that little earthquakes are much more common than big ones," said USGS seismologist Sarah Minson in a news release about the findings of the study

The findings

Seismologists took the example of an earthquake on San Andreas Fault that starts in Northern California. The simulation of a 8.o magnitude temblor has the fault rupturing toward San Francisco.

https://prd-wret.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/production/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/ezgif.com-video-to-gif.gif

They found the earliest possible time San Francisco residents could be warned was about 48 seconds ahead of the strong shaking. If they waited for strong shaking to begin, there would be only 8 seconds of warning.